What Should I Do with the Family Cottage?

This can be one of the most prickly questions when planning a Will.


For many families, the cottage or recreational property is more than just a place for family gatherings. It is a trove of memories that bind the family together. This is especially true if the cottage has been in the family for generations.


Some family members might not even see the cottage as the property of the sole title holder. To them, it’s the collective property of the family. This can make dealing with the family cottage difficult in a Will.


Important things to consider:

o   Do you want to keep the cottage in the family or sell it to an outsider?

o   Is the cottage your principal residence? If it isn’t, the transfer of the cottage after your death will likely generate taxable capital gains. It doesn’t matter whether you transfer it to a family member or sell it to an outsider, or when you do so.


Once you know what you want to do, speak to your lawyer and financial advisor about your options, some of which are set out below:


Option 1 – transfer the cottage to your children in equal shares


o   Simple, straightforward and fair to your children



o   Difficult if some children live far away from the cottage
o   Children have to share maintenance of the cottage, which can be a problem if they have different levels of income or interest
o   Your estate may have to pay capital gains tax


If you choose this option, you might consider buying life insurance to cover possible capital gains tax.


Option 2 – transfer the cottage to only one of your children


o   Good option if one child visits the cottage regularly and maintains it



o   You might have to equalize the inheritances through gifts of other assets and life insurance proceeds


Don’t be afraid to consider this option. If your children have moved to other cities or provinces, they may have lost interest in the cottage or just can’t make use of it.


Option 3 – sell the cottage under your Will


o   Good option if your children are not interested in the cottage or have moved away

o   You can sell the cottage and split the proceeds equally between your children so they can buy their own cottages (or not)



o   If the cottage was not your principal residence, you may have to pay capital gains tax


Once again, you can prepare for this capital gains tax by purchasing life insurance.


Option 4 - transfer the cottage to a non-profit corporation


o   Cottage can be kept in the family for generations

o   Membership fees paid by family members would cover upkeep



o   You would need to pay some capital gains tax when the cottage is first transferred to the corporation

o   Complicated procedure for which you’ll definitely need legal and financial planning advice


This is a creative way to keep the cottage in the family. You can transfer it, either in your Will or during your lifetime, to a non-profit corporation. Your family members would become corporation members and would have to pay membership fees. These fees would pay for the maintenance of the cottage. You can draft the by-laws of the non-profit corporation so that a family member who doesn’t pay fees would not be allowed to use the cottage.


Other Options
The above options may not work for you. Consult with your family members, your lawyer and your financial advisor to pick the best one for you.
Wills On Wheels Free Publication
Sign Up & Receive A Free Download 'Getting Ready To Meet Your Lawyer - 10 Top Things To Do'
Related Stories
Types Of Wills
Learn about the three types of wills and about Will Kits.... Read More
Naming an Executor
Believe it or not, you may not be the most important person in your Will. Learn about this important role and how you choose an executor.... Read More
What Are the Duties of an Executor?
Learn about the responsibilities of an Executor.... Read More
Providing for Children
What does it mean to name someone as guardian for a child and who may be considered a "child".... Read More
Benefit of Pre-Planning a Funeral
Learn how to avoid family disputes with a good funeral and burial plan.... Read More
Special Bequests and Family Heirlooms
When you divide up your assets in your Will, sometimes it takes more than a calculator, learn how to handle special bequests and family heirlooms.... Read More
Where to Store A Will
Learn the about the importance of storing a Will in a place where your Executor will find it.... Read More
More Articles About Wills and Estates